Last updated: January 17th, 2023 at 12:07 UTC+01:00


I don't care about your S Pen, Samsung

Danny Dorresteijn

Reading time: 3 minutes

s pen pro 2
Opinion
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
Ever since the Galaxy Note line was killed off, the S Pen has become less of an exclusive feature for Samsung phones and more of a standard feature that you get if buy either of its costliest two phones (a Galaxy S Ultra or a Galaxy Z Fold) every year.

The Galaxy S22 Ultra came with a built-in slot for the S Pen stylus last year, and the Galaxy S23 Ultra will follow that trend, as the leaks and rumors have told us. And, well, at the risk of sounding like a broken record, I have just one thing to say to Samsung: I don't care about the S Pen, and it's unfortunate that it is being forced on everyone who wants the top Galaxy S model at the moment.

The reason is quite simple: the inclusion of the S Pen on the Galaxy S Ultra smartphones has messed up the awesome and crazy ideal design and form that the company managed to achieve with the Galaxy S21 Ultra. The S21 Ultra has S Pen support just like the Galaxy S22 Ultra and the upcoming Galaxy S23 Ultra, but it doesn't have a dedicated S Pen slot, and it's all the better for it.

Advertisement

The Galaxy S21 Ultra had pretty much the most comfortable and ergonomic designs Samsung ever came up with for its large-screen flagships. Its corners were rounded just right, and it was also narrower so customers could more easily use it with one hand. The S Pen was optional because it didn't come in the box or sit inside the phone itself, and that was a much better solution in my opinion.

The S Pen should have remained an optional accessory

The Galaxy S22 Ultra, on the other hand, carries the traditional Note design. That means it's too wide and a pain to use at times, with rather sharp corners that dig into your palm. If you put a case on, things get even more uncomfortable. The same will no doubt be the case with the upcoming Galaxy S23 Ultra, and the reason for all that is the S Pen.

Look, the S Pen is a great tool, and Samsung offers the best stylus experience on both smartphones and tablets. But it simply isn't a tool that's used or desired by most people, including myself and at least two of my colleagues. Most of us would prefer a bigger battery or a bigger camera sensor, and, again, the near-ideal design of the Galaxy S21 Ultra, as mentioned above.

Advertisement

Note fans will probably shake their heads at the suggestion, but when you look at it objectively, a built-in S Pen slot is more of a hindrance than something that improves the day-to-day experience. I won't say Samsung needs to bring back the Galaxy Note lineup, as the Korean giant is hoping to make foldables more popular and killing the Note brand was a necessary step, but I do wish it would make the S Pen optional again.

Sadly, it is highly improbable Samsung will actually remove the S Pen slot from the Galaxy S Ultra smartphones, considering how the company wants to sell the top Galaxy S model as the phone that has everything one could ask for and not lose its Galaxy Note fanbase, at least until foldable phones become a viable option for everyone.

Advertisement

But one can dream, right?