We got the best Samsung deals! Galaxy S24 Ultra, Watch 6, Z Fold 5 or, Z Flip 5.

SamMobile has affiliate and sponsored partnerships. If you buy something through one of these links, we may earn a commission.

Notifications
    News for you

    Samsung’s smartwatches should be running Android Wear instead of Tizen

    Opinion
    By 

    Last updated: April 1st, 2015 at 16:02 UTC+02:00

    Samsung has been at the forefront of wearable devices ever since the original Galaxy Gear went on sale. The Korean manufacturer has launched three smartwatches, a fitness tracker, and a virtual reality handset since then, and it's safe to say Samsung has been moving much faster than pretty much any other company out there when it comes to wearables. Samsung is currently the number one smartwatch vendor in the world, and it is using its lead in the market to take its time with its next smartwatch – the Orbis, which will have a round display – and make it as close to perfect as possible.

    Sadly, the fact that the Orbis will run Tizen instead of Android Wear is something that just doesn't sit well with me.

    Tizen is a nice operating system. It's light, runs fast, and allows Samsung to offer much better battery life than smartwatches running Android Wear. Being Samsung's own operating system, Tizen has allowed the company to offer considerably more functionality than the competition in all its smartwatches (the original Galaxy Gear didn't run Tizen, but it ran a full version of Android and was hence as functional.) Furthermore, putting Tizen on its watches is helping Samsung eke out a wearable ecosystem of its own, one that runs on its in-house OS instead of one developed by the competition.

    Unfortunately, all this hasn't exactly resulted into the Gear watches providing the best experience when you look at the fact that a smartwatch is supposed to offer convenience and access to things that you would usually take out your phone to do. The fact that we can get relevant data from various apps right on our wrist is one of the few reasons that justifies the existence of the smartwatch product category, but thanks to the Gear watches running Tizen instead of Android, we have seen a dearth of supported apps despite the first Gear smartwatch having come out almost two years ago.

    Compare this with Android Wear. It's been less than a year since the first Android Wear smartwatch hit markets (you can read our Gear Live review here), and we can already see a ton of popular apps offering support for the OS (the fact that Google makes it extremely easy for developers to port their apps to Android Wear helps considerably). These apps offer functionality that you couldn't do before without taking out your phone – for example, you can book a taxi using apps like Uber right from your wrist, or reply to a tweet using voice control on Twitter apps that support it.

    SAMSUNG CSC

    There are a lot of other use cases for apps on a smartwatch, but they all require the developer to actually spend time building in those functions for the smartwatch version of their app. On Android Wear, we have seen a lot of apps bring such features to the smartwatch, but on Samsung's in-house Gear watches, developers haven't really been interested in doing the same. The result? Apps that basically only show you notifications without the option to act on them or perform a task right from the watch.

    There's another feature – or the lack thereof – that really puts Samsung's Gear smartwatches behind those powered by Android Wear. That's Google Now, Google's personal digital and voice assistant. Google's voice recognition technology is pretty much unmatched in the industry, and it is considerably superior to Samsung's S Voice, which is preloaded on every Gear smartwatch. Then there's the fact that S Voice doesn't do any of the intelligent assistant stuff that Google Now is capable of (basically, presenting you with important information before you ask for it), and it becomes even more agitating that we don't have access to Google Now on any of Samsung's Tizen-powered watches.

    I totally understand why Samsung is doing this. In its efforts to create its own ecosystem which can help it reduce its independence on other companies, making every smartwatch run Tizen makes sense. But it also means that we are stuck with two huge limitations – the lack of functional smartwatch apps and an amazing voice recognition/digital assistant technology. The former is something Samsung can't really help (though developers naturally aren't too interested in making apps for watches that won't run with a non-Samsung phone or tablet, even if the Korean manufacturer is responsible for a majority of Android device sales), but the fact that something like Google Now isn't available to users just because Samsung wants to use its own OS on its wearables is one that doesn't sit too well with me.

    Unless Samsung can reach a level of competence where it can challenge Google as far as lack of apps and brilliant voice recognition is concerned, I really don't see any point of any Gear smartwatch running Tizen. The Orbis might be shaping up to one of the best smartwatches the world has ever seen, but considering the high prices of smartwatches and their lack of the aforementioned functionality on Samsung's Gears, it's ultimately a poor experience for end users.

    P.S.: If one were to point out that Android Wear is quite limited, I would agree wholeheartedly (especially when you talk of battery life). But Android Wear can only grow more powerful and more functional as time passes, and unless Samsung can address the two biggest issues its smartwatches have, there's really not much point spending so much on a Tizen-powered watch. 

    Opinion Android WearGearOrbis

    You might also like

    [Poll] Still interested in Samsung’s Android Wear watches? Google is

    [Poll] Still interested in Samsung’s Android Wear watches? Google is

    Android Wear on Samsung hardware is a big deal post-2016. Regardless of whether or not you've forgotten that it was a deal in the first place, which I totally did not and it absolutely is. You know, as absolute as such a statement can be, not coming directly from Samsung. But don't worry, that's still pretty […]

    • By Dominik Bosnjak
    • 3 years ago
    Samsung switching to Android Wear (Watch OS) for its smartwatches?

    Samsung switching to Android Wear (Watch OS) for its smartwatches?

    Trademark applications filed by Samsung had suggested the possibility of the company moving to the Galaxy branding for its wearable devices, perhaps to unify its product lineups across the smartphone and wearable categories, but a new rumor is hinting that it may not be just a name change. According to leakster Ice universe, Samsung may […]

    • By Abhijeet Mishra
    • 6 years ago
    Tizen overtakes Android Wear in smartwatch market share

    Tizen overtakes Android Wear in smartwatch market share

    The Gear Live was Samsung's first and only Android Wear-powered smartwatch. It was released back in 2014 and while many thought that Samsung would launch another one, the company confirmed last year that it will no longer make Android Wear smartwatches. Samsung said that it would only make smartwatches that run on its Tizen platform. […]

    • By Adnan Farooqui
    • 7 years ago
    Samsung is revolutionizing in-store retail operations with Fujitsu

    Samsung is revolutionizing in-store retail operations with Fujitsu

    Samsung has teamed up with Fujitsu to revolutionize in-store retail operations. At the National Retail Federation's Big Show in New York City, Fujitsu launched a new software solution that creates a secure two-way collaborative digital communication platform between the company's U-Scan Self-Checkout (SCO) or Fresco Point-of-Sale (POS) touchscreen systems and Samsung's smartwatches. This new system […]

    • By Adnan Farooqui
    • 7 years ago
    How Samsung singlehandedly brought down Android Wear

    How Samsung singlehandedly brought down Android Wear

    It wasn't all that long ago that Samsung and Google were arguing over Samsung's Tizen efforts, and, since that argument some 2 years ago, Samsung has continued to build Tizen and its own platform ecosystem. Well, LG, Huawei, and Motorola have sat out the last several months of 2016 in the smartwatch market, but news this past week from […]

    • By Deidre R.
    • 7 years ago
    Samsung’s abandonment of Android Wear has Android Wear OEMs applauding

    Samsung’s abandonment of Android Wear has Android Wear OEMs applauding

    I wrote some months ago that Android Wear fans shouldn't get their hopes up about a 2016 Samsung Android Wear smartwatch, and I still stand by the statements I made then. What's new, though, is that it appears as if even Android Wear agrees with Samsung. Back 4 months ago, it seemed as though Samsung was rebelling […]

    • By Deidre R.
    • 7 years ago